Sunday, September 18, 2011


by Ducky Paredes
MALAYA, Business Insight, 05 September 2011
(Original article available here)

"PEOPLE and multinational corporations both have birthdays but with a big difference. Humans tend to become kinder as they approach the end of their time on earth; multinationals get to be more powerful and, as their reach expands, more dominant, exploitative and even criminally abusive. Not all, of course; as with humans, there are good and bad multinationals.

One multinational celebrated its hundredth year recently by bullying and throwing its weight around to the detriment, not just of its competitors, but also even of its own business partners.

At last, the multinational is getting its comeuppance. For starters, the force of the law, imperfect as it is in this country, seems to be working against the multinational. A judge is looking them over and entertaining complaints filed by Pinoys who were abused by the MNC and forced into a state of near-bankruptcy.

There is even more trouble due the MNC in the form of bills pending in the Senate and the House of Representatives intended to improve current laws against monopolistic behavior, predatory pricing and restraint of trade, sponsored by Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile, Senator Sergio OsmeƱa and Representative Rufus Rodriguez. .

The giant multinational, which is Nestle Philippines, Inc. (NPI), just turned 100 recently. Nestle, as with most other MNCs, celebrated its longevity by launching corporate social responsibility (CSR) projects backed up by lavish advertisements in print, radio, television and cinema showing how the multinational has been a good corporate citizen. In the case of Nestle in the Philippines, one wonders whether this the true picture of the company.

NPI’s festivities were somewhat rained on when the Office of the City Prosecutor of Quezon City issued a resolution on August 15 finding sufficient evidence to hold NPI for trial for violation of Article 186 of the Revised Penal Code.

This article penalizes any person "who shall enter into any contract or agreement or shall take part in any conspiracy or combination in the form of a trust or otherwise, which results in restraint of trade or commerce and prevents, by artificial means, free competition in the market."

The resolution found merit in the complaint filed by Nestle distributors FDI Forefront II Trading Corporation and Service Edge Distributors, Inc. that their agreements with Nestle were anti-competitive since they were obligated to sell Nestle products at the price fixed by NPI, regardless of the fact that the set price provided too thin a margin for the distributors to make a profit. Failure by the distributors to sell under these terms would result in the unilateral termination of their agreement with NPI. Their complaint pointed to a situation when NPI forced them to sell to a set of customers at a loss because of the fixed price set by NPI.

According to the QC Prosecutor’s resolution, "the act of Nestle in fixing the resale price maintenance for its products, imposing it on complainant is illegal, a per se violation of paragraph 1 of Article 186, Revised Penal Code which means that price fixing is automatically illegal and there will be no valid justification to legitimate price fixing agreement."

The resolution further stated that an analysis of the agreement shows that the act is also unlawful "because of its harmful anti-competitive effects against consumers and complainants, with no competitive economic benefits. Harmful to the consumers because Nestle exercised monopoly power of price fixing, the resale of its goods which means that consumers cannot buy the product at a lower price than that fixed by Nestle."

High ranking NPI executives, former Chief Executive Officer Doreswamy Nandkishore, current CEO John Martin Miller, Shahab Bahcani and Peter Noszek were impleaded for conspiring to commit anti-competitive acts as they were found to have knowingly committed the crime or to have permitted or failed to prevent the commission of the crime, and will stand trial before a Regional Trial Court of Quezon City.

The resolution is a welcome development, not only to the complainants, but to those who support the passage of an Anti-Trust Law, coming as it does on the heels of President Noynoy Aquino’s signing of Executive Order No. 45 giving full jurisdiction to the Department of Justice over matters related to competition and fair trade practices.

Lawyer Lorna P. Kapunan recalled the president’s assurance that the matter of monopolies and corporate bullying tactics was one of the first issues that he would look into. "His signing that E.O. shows that he is taking active steps to back up his promise," Kapunan said.

Nestle insiders say that the top honchos in the company’s main office in Switzerland are closely monitoring the woes that the local hundred-year-old outfit is experiencing. The rift between NPI and its distributors was reportedly on the agenda when the mother company’s chief executive Paul Burke and executive vice president Frits Van Dijk came all the way from Switzerland to meet with NPI officials (and also incidentally, to participate in the company’s centennial celebration).

Will the mother company in Switzerland do anything to convert the image of the centenarian company into a more grandfatherly one in its dealings with its business partners or will Nestle continue to exhibit the worst traits of a MNC monster?"


  1. The much larger the pearl, the rarer they
    are really and the much more high priced. People are still talking about
    it today, even though she has had a whole new set
    of commitment rings (commitment, not wedding,
    people) with Brad Pitt. Should you're planning to buy jewelry with gemstones, it is really also critical to be aware of no matter if the stones are all-natural or if their colours were enhanced.

    Feel free to surf to my website ... promise rings for her meaning

  2. Unique Inlays: Unique inlays in tungsten rings consist of shell, carbon fiber and wood.

    Sources: Amanda Greene, "With this ring, I thee shed. The historical origins of the friendship rings stretches back to the Ancient world.

    my weblog website

  3. Unique Inlays: Unique inlays in tungsten rings consist of shell, carbon fiber and wood.
    People are still talking about it today, even though she has
    had a whole new set of commitment rings (commitment, not wedding, people) with Brad Pitt.
    A pre-wedding ring –engagement ring is
    given usually to commit acceptance of eternal marital

    my web page - promise rings in new york

  4. As being a protection mechanism, the oyster wraps the organic
    substance having a substance referred to as nacre, resulting to what is referred to as mommy of pearl.
    A youngster can choose from a basic sterling silver ring or a high-end ring which
    incorporates diamonds or birthstones. Silver rings are something
    of a craze among the couples because they are relatively cheaper than other metals.

    Take a look at my homepage ... promise rings 50 under

  5. However, small diamonds placed in a setting of yellow
    or white gold are quite common as promise rings for those who can afford them.
    If you're planning on shopping around for diamond anniversary rings be sure to also find some good ideas about how to present the ring. Older cameos had been generally manufactured with celluloid utilizing two hues.

    Here is my webpage ... site

  6. You just have to be certain whom you give the
    promise ring to. After me and my boyfriend (Terry) had been together for a year, we decided
    to buy each other promise rings to symbolize our love and commitment.

    CZ rings get a bad rap because they are often sold at cheap-o
    shops like Claire's and Spencer's, but if you purchase a CZ promise ring that
    is set on an 18k gold band, the ring will look very high quality and expensive.

    Feel free to visit my website :: promise rings jared jewelers ()

  7. Cultured pearls of all types may be found in jewelry shops worldwide.

    It's just up to you what type of rings you want to gift your loved one. A blue-white diamond appears quite unique and distinctive, but actually, this style of diamond is of lesser high quality ' though
    the jeweler will try to generate you're thinking that you happen to be getting something exclusive.

    my webpage ... promise rings for women